Yeah like anything composition over individual toon capability.
Agree Erika is versatile even if placed on a melee team forces a different way of playing. Shiva control makes her offense and defense effective. Mirabell is well rounded and neuter gov will be a huge asset.
I’d rank hershel over guardian zeke only cause he can hold a stun gun, but abs defense is also hugely effective and the blue powers can kill hershel pretty quickly.
Michonne gator Maggie surprise me. I’ve yet to see them really be a game changer but I’m sure depends on your individual strength.
Overall good list. Maybe I’ll take a gander at listing them by my preference later today if I find the time.